Sunday, 15 May 2016

Heinz Birkholz, 1922-2016



This website owes its existence to the work of Heinz Birkholz.

The dedicated reader of this blog will have noticed recurring references to some of the pioneers of German aviation research of the 1919 to 1945 period: Hans Redemann, Karl Ries, Karl R. Pawlas, J. Richard Smith, Eddie J. Creek, Thomas Hitchcock, or Heinz Birkholz. It is Heinz Birkholz in particular who ranks among the earliest writers to make a dedicated effort to confront misinformation, myth, and previously uncharted territory by means of publishing serious research and prime source material. Moreover, in the course of his decades of activities as a journalist and editor, Birkholz managed to bring together an illustrious group of contributors consisting of period protagonists on one hand and fellow experts of German aviation on the other. This included notables such as Karl Kössler, Günther Ott, Roy Nesbit, Günter Frost, Richard Chapman, and many others.



Born in 1922, Heinz Birkholz served in World War II as one of the German Luftwaffe's schwarze Männer (i.e., as a member of the ground crew), in his case as a technician assigned to Jagdgeschwader 5 in Norway. In 1944, he was transferred to Flugzeugführerschule [pilot school] A/B 23 in Kaufbeuren, Bavaria, where, like many others, he underwent training to become a pilot in an attempt to replenish the staggeringly mounting personnel losses of the Luftwaffe. The war ended before he flew a first operational mission, however, and Birkholz re-entered civilian life as a journalist with the Hamburger Morgenpost newspaper.

But it really was his continuing interest in aviation which was to define Birkholz' life. In the 1960s, he became one of the very first European journalists to regularly cover the hobby of plastic modelling in the press, by writing for Modellbau-Revue magazine. Moreover, he contributed to other specialist periodicals, such as the renown aviation magazine Flug Revue.



Before long, Birkholz' column about plastic kits in Modellbau-Revue became increasingly popular, and the idea for a magazine solely dedicated to plastic modelling gained traction. This finally became reality in March of 1970, when Plastik Modell was launched. Heinz Birkholz was the magazine's creative director and chief editor. But Plastik Modell wasn't simply a magazine covering plastic kits. Not only did it feature detailed articles that illuminated the histories and technical details of the actual full-size aircraft that were the subject of the kits, but it also contained an innovative readers' letters forum in which readers, photo collectors, and fellow researchers exchanged further information and contributed rare photos. This was the prototype of a highly successful and prolific concept Birkholz would henceforth apply to all of his subsequent publications.

In 1974, Birkholz established a dedicated pictorial extension to Plastik Modell by creating PM Foto-Revue. This was a photo album-type publication which contained further previously unpublished pictures of historic subjects, submitted from the private collections of both writers and readers of Plastik Modell. Regrettably, the publisher, G. Schmidt-Verlag, ceased operations just as PM Foto-Revue was launched.



But instead of giving up, Birkholz and his editorial team professionalised their efforts and went on to found the new periodical Modell Magazin, which, starting in 1975, covered both scale models and aviation history, and subsequently became one of the most important and influential publications within the growing Luftwaffe research community. In 1976, following the earlier example set with Plastik Modell, Modell Magazin introduced Modell Magazin Foto Archiv, its own softcover photo album offspring. Published sporadically until the early 1980s, Modell Magazin Foto Archiv again featured period pictures submitted by the writers and readers of the magazine and thus exposed extraordinary treasures to a wider audience.



When Modell Magazin eventually changed direction and content in the mid-1980s, Birkholz left and established a new magazine, Flugzeug, dedicated entirely to aviation, both in scale and history. In 1988, Flugzeug continued the tradition of its predecessors by launching an infrequently published offspring softcover photo album, Flugzeug Archiv. One final time, history repeated itself when Birkholz, after internal disagreements, left Flugzeug to establish Jet & Prop in 1991. The by now inevitable offspring photo periodical, Jet & Prop Foto Archiv, was first published in 1992.



By the end of 2000 and aged 78, Heinz Birkholz felt it was time to transfer Jet & Prop's reins into younger hands. The magazine still exists to this day, and for a while after his "retirement", Birkholz was still a contributor to both the magazine proper and Jet & Prop Foto Archiv.

The importance of Heinz Birkholz' near life-long efforts with regard to the Luftwaffe research community cannot be overstated. Generations of young readers first came in contact with the topic through his magazines, uncounted researchers and collectors were able to first publish their findings in the pages of his publications, and the readers' letters forum was a crucial pre-internet age platform for the exchange of information, new discoveries, or the placement of specialist questions or requests for research assistance. And Birkholz' dedicated photo publications were an inexhaustible source of unpublished photos.



For decades, Birkholz' specialist magazines were the place where one would frequently find spectacular historic German aviation research discoveries and hitherto unknown images of elusive aircraft types. One might remember the ground-breaking articles on the Junkers Ju 88 H, the Heinkel He 176, the Henschel Hs 132, or the Fieseler Fi 168, to name but a few of so many.



Last but not least, the author of this blog was himself one the aforementioned young readers when, in 1975 and at age 12, he first discovered Modell Magazin und from then on religiously followed everything and anything published by Heinz Birkholz, eventually beginning to build his own dedicated library and photo collection. And, many years later, this blog.

Heinz Birkholz passed away on March 20, 2016, at age 93. He is buried, anonymously, at Hamburg-Öjendorf cemetery.

Header photo of Heinz Birkholz originally published in Modell Magazin 4/1984.

Sunday, 27 December 2015

Focke-Wulf A 17


The prototype Focke-Wulf A 17 V1 Möwe [gull] passenger aircraft D-1149 Bremen, Werknummer 32, built in 1927. D-1149 was powered by a Gnome et Rhône 9A Jupiter engine and could carry eight passengers. It was operated by Norddeutsche LVG and also flew for Deutsche Lufthansa. The photo, unfortunately slightly out of focus, was taken at Borkum island in the North Sea, apparently in 1929.

The A 17's passenger cabin measured 3.5 meters in length, 1.5 meters in width, and 1.8 meters in height, and the design provided for four crank operated windows port and starboard. The eight forward-facing passenger seats had adjustable seat backs. The cabin was furnished with lights, curtains, luggage nets, coat hooks, hand holds, and a toilet in the rear. The entry door was located on the port side, and there was an escape hatch in the cabin ceiling. In addition to the passenger cabin, the A 17 also featured two dedicated luggage compartments. (German Aviation 1919-1945 collection)

[Entry amended January 17, 2020.]

Wednesday, 23 December 2015

Focke-Wulf Fw 44



Moment of partial touch-down by a Focke-Wulf Fw 44 Stieglitz [goldfinch] two-seat biplane trainer ?G+AD (possibly CG+AD), powered by a Siemens Sh 14 radial engine. Aircraft appears to be painted in standard dark green camouflage, with undersides in 65 and a yellow fuselage band.

This Fw 44 was photographed during the final four years of the war; location unknown. The inscription on the back of the photograph simply reads: Landung im Schnee [snow landing]. (German Aviation 1919-1945 collection)

[Entry amended January 17, 2020.]

Friday, 18 December 2015

Les Avions Francais Aux Couleurs Allemandes, Volume 1























Philippe Ricco, Horse-Série Avions #40, Edition Lela Presse, Le Vigen, France, 2015, ISSN 1253-5354. Illustrated, softcover, published in French.

Cover image © by Edition Lela Presse, 2015.


Latest in a long-standing series of noteworthy aviation publications by Lela Presse, this beautiful softcover publication provides a dedicated look at aircraft of French provenance in German service following the German invasion of France in 1940. Philippe Ricco's Les Avions Francais Aux Couleurs Allemandes [French aircraft in German colours] is a magazine-type publication of standard A4 size, featuring 112 pages and 250 photos (some in colour), and it includes 30 well-rendered colour profiles. Moreover, this is actually the first installment of what is intended to be a multi-part study, and it covers aircraft produced by Amiot, Arsenal, Bloch, Breguet, CAMS, Caudron, and Delanne.

Ricco's work focuses mainly on photographic coverage; only brief sections of text are included. The paper quality and photo reproduction are quite excellent, and each image is accompanied by a detailed caption. Where available, the individual aircraft type entries include lists of known codes, units, and other information. The wealth of images collected for this publication is remarkable, and while a certain number of photos have been published before, Les Avions Francais Aux Couleurs Allemandes serves as a competent and complete one-stop compilation.

As has been pointed out on this blog before, and as any serious student of our topic of choice will agree, a publication featuring exceptional content should really serve to render any potential language barriers irrelevant. And many of the photos contained in Les Avions Francais Aux Couleurs Allemandes are indeed exceptional. In addition to numerous very clear shots, there are also many remarkable camouflage schemes and several interesting detail views. Uncredited (captioned simply as deux officiers allemands), on page 27, top, is what appears to be Luftwaffe Generalfeldmarschall [field marshall] Hugo Sperrle, in front of a Bloch 200.

Volume 2 of this excellent new series will apparently cover aircraft by Dewoitine to Stark, and the publishers also promise to include any corrections/amendments provided by the readers of the previous volume. Very commendable, and very recommended.

Monday, 14 December 2015

Focke-Wulf Fw 190



Unidentified early Focke-Wulf Fw 190 A in what appears to be the standard camouflage of 74/75/76. Underside of cowling appears to be yellow 04. The lack of the forward fuselage extension (introduced on the Fw 190 A-5), along with the presence of the panel line on the air intake duct on the side of the cowling (introduced on the Fw 190 A-1), narrows the possible subtype down to either an Fw 190 A-1, A-2, A-3, or A-4.

The temporary inscription on the propeller has unfortunately so far proven illegible, except for the number "82". (German Aviation 1919-1945 collection; additional information very kindly supplied by Steve Sheflin and Leon Venter, via luftwaffe-research-group.org)

[Entry amended January 17, 2020.]

Thursday, 10 December 2015

Henschel Hs 123



Crashed Henschel Hs 123 A-1 L2+KM of Lehrgeschwader 2 (LG 2), likely photographed at Tutow, late 1930s (exact date currently unknown to me). Camouflage is the early style of 61/62/63/65. It appears that the aircraft suffered a mishap which sheared off its fixed landing gear, as evidenced by the damage to propeller.

Parts of the aircraft have apparently already been salvaged, and the missing forward fuselage panels and cowling reveal the BMW 132 Dc radial engine. A section of the detached upper wing can be seen in the foreground. (German Aviation 1919-1945 collection)

[Entry amended January 17, 2020.]

Sunday, 6 December 2015

Dornier Do 17





Wreckage of what appears to have been a pristine and somewhat nondescript Dornier Do 17 Z. The aircraft seems to have been partially disassembled after the mishap, its wings stored neatly next to the fuselage. The camouflage scheme is very likely standard 70/71/65.

Unfortunately, even a detail enlargement (lower photo) doesn't provide for a positive identification of the emblem(s) on the forward fuselage. Exact circumstances, date, and location are unknown to me at this time. (German Aviation 1919-1945 collection)

[Entry amended January 18, 2020]

Thursday, 3 December 2015

German Aircraft Instrument Panels Vol. 1

























[Full title: German Aircraft Instrument Panels Vol. 1 - Bf 109 F-4, Bf 110 E, Fi 156, Fw 190 A-3, Hs 123 A, Ju 88 A-4] Dariusz Karnas, Inside Series, Mushroom Model Publications/Stratus s.c., Sandomierz, Poland, 2014, ISBN 978-83-63678-55-5. Illustrated, hardcover, published in English.

Cover image © by Mushroom Model Publications/Stratus s.c., 2014.


This first volume of a potentially substantial series of reference works by Dariusz Karnas is a superb and very welcome publication. The instrument panel of each aircraft featured in German Aircraft Instrument Panels Vol. 1 is described in a section of four to six pages, and each such section contains a minimum of text plus black & white photos, lavish colour renderings of the instrument panel and the individual instruments and gunsights, and, at times, additional drawings taken from the aircraft's handbook.

Needless to say, the colour renderings are the main focus of the book. They are quite accurate and realistic, and some of the individual instruments are depicted at near their original size. The instrument panels themselves are shown both completed and bare, the bare versions being captioned with numbers and corresponding lists of applicable instruments. The individual instruments feature their original German designations and parts numbers as well as the appropriate English designations.

In spite of the orientation of the cover, German Aircraft Instrument Panels Vol. 1 is actually a landscape format book (sized 30 x 22 cm), which permits a larger reproduction of the instrument panels than would have been possible had a portrait format been chosen. Having said that, the nature of large colour renderings, in combination with the somewhat odd choice of a light brown background, at first glance make this publication appear almost like a children's book. But the realism and amount of detail featured are absolutely stunning.

Frustratingly, however, there are also shortcomings. At a meagre 38 pages, and featuring the instrument panels of a mere six aircraft types, the actual content of German Aircraft Instrument Panels Vol. 1 is disappointingly moderate. This is a bit of a shame. While the subject matter will, by necessity, require multiple volumes at any rate, it would have been nice if individual volumes would have been produced as slightly more substantial works of reference.

Moreover, while I do understand that both publisher and author will have to adhere to self-imposed limits to keep a publication within a realistic scope and price range, Karnas has elected to omit any other cockpit details, such as instrumented side panels, controls, ancillary equipment, or seats. Or the rear of the instrument panels, for that matter. The small amounts of text contained provide a brief overview of the aircraft types, but no information whatsoever with regard to the instrument panels themselves or their development. While all of these omissions undoubtedly reflect conscious decisions by the author, the inclusion of such content easily would have made German Aircraft Instrument Panels Vol. 1 an indispensable standard work on the topic.

As it is, however, this indisputably lovely book is best used in conjunction with existing publications in order to obtain a more complete picture of the subject matter. There are some that are quite essential, such as Peter W. Cohausz's substantial hardcover study Cockpits Deutscher Flugzeuge [German Aircraft Cockpits] (Aviatic Verlag GmbH, 2000), or the same author's Cockpit Profile softcover series (Flugzeug Publikations GmbH, 1998-2000). And then there is, of course, Kenneth H. Merrick's extensive but equally frustratingly incomplete German Aircraft Interiors 1935 - 1945 - Vol. 1 (Monogram Aviation Publications, 1996); another book that could/should have become a standard work for decades to come.

Tuesday, 28 July 2015

Udet U 11





The sole Udet U 11 Kondor [condor] Grossverkehrsflugzeug [large airliner], Werknummer 243, photographed in January 1926 at Oberschleissheim airfield north of Munich, with test pilot Harry Rother. The aircraft is still in pristine condition and devoid of any markings; it would later be assigned the fuselage code D-828. First flown by Rother on January 19, 1926, the U 11 was powered by four Siemens & Halske Sh 12 air-cooled radial engines with aerodynamic fairings, extended driveshafts (necessitated due to the pusher configuration), and two-blade propellers.

The U 11 was the largest aircraft produced by Udet Flugzeugbau, München-Ramersdorf, following an order by Deutscher Aero Loyd. As is beautifully illustrated by the photos, it was an open-cockpit design with side-by-side seating for the two pilots. The navigator's station was located in the very front of the aircraft, ahead of the pilots. The fuselage was constructed from Duralumin profiles and covered by Duralumin sheets. It could seat eight passengers and also contained a toilet and a luggage compartment.

The wings, featuring two main spars, were manufactured from wood, with fabric covering and a plywood-reinforced leading edge. The empennage consisted of Duralumin tubing and profiles, also covered with fabric. The landing gear was fitted with a then rather common rubber suspension system and 1100 by 220mm main wheels.

Rother's test flights revealed significant design shortcomings, and the aircraft's service career with Deutsche Lufthansa (successor to Deutscher Aero Loyd) was correspondingly brief. The U 11 subsequently crashed during the delivery flight to Deutsche Verkehrsfliegerschule [German air transport school]. The failure of the U 11 was among the reasons for the financial failure of Udet Flugzeugbau and its eventual acquisition by Bayerische Flugzeugwerke AG (BFW). At least one of the above photos appears to have been an official release by BFW, as it bears a company stamp on the rear.

Enlargements of sections of the second photo posted above reveal a number of interesting details (below).

[Entry amended January 20, 2020]





Monday, 27 July 2015

Focke-Wulf Fw 58


Inspection of the starboard Argus As 10 engine of a Focke-Wulf Fw 58 C Weihe [harrier] liaison aircraft, photographed at Cottbus, near Berlin. Unfortunately, none of the aircraft's markings are visible, thus rendering a more detailed identification difficult.

The inscription on the back of the original photograph reads: Vor dem Start [before take-off]. The exact date is unknown, although judging by the attire of some of the mechanics, the picture appears to have been taken in summer. (German Aviation 1919-1945 collection)

[Entry amended January 19, 2020]